The witch hazel sold as "water" and the witch hazel found in a dermocosmetic formula are often not the same thing. A distillate contains only the plant's volatile components, but tannins—the molecules responsible for much of its activity—are not volatile. The name on the label is identical; the contents are not.
Article by Elisa Avalle, founder of LeLang Skin Care and dermocosmetics specialist. Cover image generated with the support of artificial intelligence.
[INDICE:h2]What is witch hazel?
Hamamelis virginiana is a shrub native to North America, similar to a hazel tree, with oval leaves that have toothed edges. In cosmetics, extracts made from the leaves are used most often, and sometimes those from the bark.
On the label, it appears as Hamamelis Virginiana Leaf Extract, Hamamelis Virginiana Bark Extract, or Hamamelis Virginiana Water. These three names are not interchangeable, and this is the central point of this article.
What it really contains
Analysis of the 60% ethanol extract shows three groups of compounds:
- gallic acid;
- quercetol, a flavonol;
- tannins, including hamamelitannin, which is characteristic of the plant.
Tannins are large, non-volatile molecules. This means that a steam distillation process—the one used to produce "waters"—by its very nature does not carry them into the final product. They remain in the residue. What passes through are volatile compounds, in modest amounts.
This is not a flaw in the distillate; it's how distillation works. The problem arises when properties documented for the extract are attributed to witch hazel water, which is something else entirely.
The second issue: alcohol
Many commercially available witch hazel distillates contain alcohol as a preservative, often in significant amounts. On skin that is already reactive, the effect can be the opposite of what you're looking for: a stinging sensation, dryness, and redness after application. If your skin is sensitive, it's worth checking where Alcohol or Alcohol Denat. appears in the INCI list.
The extract's dual action
Witch hazel is recognized as having a dual effect on the venous system, due to two different groups of molecules.
- Increased venous tone, attributed to catechin tannins made up of leucoanthocyanins. This is venotonic action in the strict sense.
- Vitamin P activity, due to flavonoids: reduced capillary permeability and increased venous resistance. This is the same group of effects we discuss in connection with rutin and horse chestnut.
In skincare, this translates into an astringent effect and helps comfort areas prone to redness.
Astringent doesn’t mean drying
"Astringent" is one of the most misunderstood words in cosmetics. It describes a temporary contraction of surface tissues caused by tannins, which precipitate surface proteins. It doesn’t describe a loss of water or lipids.
The confusion stems from the fact that traditional astringent toners were almost all alcohol-based, and alcohol dehydrates. The drying effect many people remember came from the alcohol, not the tannins. A well-formulated witch hazel extract in an alcohol-free base shouldn’t leave your skin feeling tight.
If you’re concerned about skin that flushes easily, you may also want to read Redness-prone skin: how to calm it.
NUTRALIGHT SENSITIVE Soothing face cream for sensitive, redness-prone skin With thermal water from the Piedmont Alps, for sensitive and re... Discover NUTRALIGHT SENSITIVE
The limitation
Regulatory note. Witch hazel has recognized traditional medicinal uses for varicose veins, hemorrhoids, phlebitis, and venous insufficiency. These are indications that apply to medicines, not cosmetics: under Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 and Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, a cosmetic product does not treat these conditions and cannot claim to. For persistent dilated capillaries, swelling, or pain, consult a doctor.
There’s also a lesser-known limitation. Tannins interact with other molecules: they can precipitate proteins and bind metal ions, which means their compatibility needs to be checked in a complex formula. They’re not an ingredient to add lightly to just any base.
How to choose it
Three practical criteria, in order of importance:
- Check the exact INCI name. Leaf Extract or Bark Extract indicate an extract; Water indicates a distillate or water-based solution, with little or no tannin content.
- Check whether it contains alcohol and where it appears on the ingredient list. If it’s one of the first ingredients in a product intended for sensitive skin, that’s a contradiction.
- Consider the formula as a whole. An astringent makes sense as part of a routine that hydrates and protects, not on its own.
If you’d prefer advice on a specific product you already have at home, LeLang partner pharmacists are trained to review the INCI with you and distinguish an extract from a scented water.
Not sure if it’s the right product for you?
Book a free virtual consultation: we’ll assess your skin together and create a personalized protocol.
Book your consultationFrequently asked questions
What is witch hazel in cosmetics?
Witch hazel is Hamamelis virginiana, a shrub native to North America that resembles a hazel tree. In cosmetics, extracts of the leaves and sometimes the bark are used, containing tannins, flavonoids, and gallic acid. On the skin, these components have an astringent effect and help keep areas prone to redness comfortable.
Are witch hazel water and witch hazel extract the same thing?
No. Witch hazel water is a steam distillate and contains mainly the plant's volatile compounds, while the tannins responsible for much of its activity remain in the residue. On the label, the extract appears as Hamamelis Virginiana Leaf Extract or Bark Extract, while the distillate is listed as Hamamelis Virginiana Water. The documented properties relate to the extract.
Does witch hazel dry out the skin?
Not in itself. Astringent refers to the temporary tightening of surface tissues caused by tannins, not to a loss of water or lipids. The feeling of tight skin was mainly caused by the alcohol in traditional toners. A well-formulated extract in an alcohol-free base should not leave skin feeling tight; if you have sensitive skin, check where Alcohol or Alcohol Denat. appears in the INCI.
Can a witch hazel cosmetic product help with capillaries and varicose veins?
No. Traditional uses of witch hazel for varicose veins, phlebitis, or venous insufficiency are medicinal, and cosmetics cannot treat or claim to treat these conditions. In cosmetics, witch hazel has an astringent effect and helps keep skin prone to redness comfortable. For persistent dilated capillaries, swelling, or pain, consult a doctor.
Sources for this article
- Caballero Gobern F. (2023). Leg cosmetics. Fundació IL3 - Universitat de Barcelona.
- Lintner K. (1998). "Purified plant extracts". Cosmetic & Toiletries, vol. 113, pp. 67-73.
- Nees S., Weiss D.R., Reichenbach-Klinke E. et al. (2003). "Protective effects of flavonoids contained in the red vine leaf on venular endothelium against the attack of activated blood components in vitro". Arzneimittel-Forschung / Drug Research, vol. 53, no. 5, pp. 330-341.
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on cosmetic products.
- Commission Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, common criteria for the justification of claims used in relation to cosmetic products.
On the website: Rutin in cosmetics: what it does and why it is called vitamin P · Skin pH: what it is and how it affects cosmetics · What is sensitive skin and how should you treat it?


